Opening hours 021 696 9833

Athlone · since 1974

The original Cape Town Gatsby.

Fried to order at the same counter on Old Klipfontein Road, in the shop where the Gatsby was born.

You've found it

63 Old Klipfontein Road, Athlone

Opening hours

How it started

One night in 1976.

Every Gatsby in Cape Town goes back to one hungry night on Old Klipfontein Road. This is how Rashaad Pandy tells it.

  1. Athlone · 1976

    Four men, one long night.

    Rashaad Pandy had opened Super Fisheries two years before. One evening he hired four men to clear a plot of land, and by the time the work was done, everyone was starving.

  2. The kitchen

    Nothing left in the house.

    There was no proper meal to give them. So he made do with what was there: a round Portuguese loaf, slap chips, polony and atchar.

  3. The cut

    Fill it, cut it, share it.

    He opened the loaf, packed it with the lot and cut it into wedges so everyone got a piece. “It happened by accident,” he has said since.

  4. The name

    “That's a Gatsby smash!”

    One of the four, Froggie, took a bite and named it on the spot. The Great Gatsby, with Robert Redford, was showing at the bioscope across the road. The name stuck.

  5. The next day

    Gone as fast as he made them.

    The next morning he made a few for customers at the shop. They sold as fast as he could fill them, and the Gatsby has been on the board ever since.

  6. Later on

    Round became long.

    The round loaf became a long roll: easier to cut, easier to share. The rest of Cape Town caught on, and the Gatsby became the city's own.

The history panel above the counter at Super Fisheries, with Rashaad Pandy's portrait and the heading 'History of Cape Town's quintessential street food: The Gatsby'.
The story's up on the wall inside the shop. Photo: @capetowndaytoursbyrosina

Still the original.

Half a century on, Gatsbys are made all over the Cape Flats and beyond. This is where the first one was cut, and it's still made here, to order, at 63 Old Klipfontein Road.

As Mr Pandy told the Daily Maverick in 2013, and others since. Some details, like the exact year, vary from telling to telling.

Order the original
Before the Gatsby

A fishery first.

Super Fisheries was a fish shop before it was anything else, and the fish is still why half the queue is there. Snoek, hake and calamari, fried to order while you wait.

Snoek

The Cape's own fish. Firm, rich and full of flavour, fried crisp and golden.

  • Snoek & chipsR108
  • One pieceR60

Hake

Mild, white and flaky under a crunchy batter. The classic for fish and chips, and for a fish Gatsby.

  • Hake & chipsR108
  • One pieceR60

Calamari

The word that comes up most in their Google reviews. Tender rings out of the fryer, as a portion, a roll or packed into a Gatsby.

  • Calamari & chipsR85
  • Calamari rollR74
Fried to order

Out of the fryer, onto fresh paper.

Nothing waits under a heat lamp. Your fish goes in when you order it, and from the queue you can watch it being made.

Bring cash: it's a cash-only counter.

Battered fish and slap chips on a crusty roll, wrapped in white paper.
Fish and chips on a roll. Photo from a Google review.
Worth the wait

Beat the queue.

On a Friday the line runs down the pavement. Pick a day and a time to see roughly how busy it gets, or phone your order through first.

Busy

Worth phoning ahead.

A rough guide built from what regulars say in reviews (lunchtime, Fridays, weekends and month-end are busiest). It isn't a live count.

  • Phone ahead

    Call your order through on 021 696 9833 or 083 434 7744 and collect.

  • Bring cash

    It's a cash-only counter, so draw some before you join the line.

  • Fridays

    Closed from 12h30 to 14h00 for Jumu'ah. Come early, or straight after.

Word on Klipfontein Road

Fifty years of regulars.

From people who've queued here since the eighties to visitors on their first Cape Town food tour.

4.5

on Google, from 1,466 reviews

1974

frying on Old Klipfontein Road

1976

the first Gatsby, cut here

R48

for a Baby Polony, the original

“The original Gatsby in Cape Town.”

Riaz H. · Google review

“Been eating Gatsby's and Fish&Chips from this place since 1984!”

@tarighdwellness · Instagram

“You can see your order being prepared with fresh ingredients.”

Shaheem A. · Google review

“Nothing compares to Super Fisheries.”

Hayden M. · Instagram

“No undiscovered neighbourhood secret.”

Time Out Cape Town · 2026

Written up in

  • Daily Maverick
  • Time Out
  • Saveur
  • Eat Out
  • Cape Town Tourism
  • Jacaranda FM
A Gatsby wrapped in paper, held up on an Athlone street on a sunny day.
@hakesy_vet_ket
A calamari Gatsby on white paper next to a bottle of Coke.
@traveltumz
A customer outside with a wrapped Gatsby under one arm and a bottle of Jive in the other hand.
@hakesy_vet_ket
A Gatsby, fish and chips and dipping sauces spread out on paper.
@tarighdwellness
Hands unwrapping a long Super Gatsby from its paper.
Google review
A polony Gatsby with chips and sauce, cut open on paper.
Google review
Two pieces of a Gatsby in paper, held in hand.
@hakesy_vet_ket
A calamari Gatsby cut open on a white plate.
Google review
The Super Fisheries shopfront on Old Klipfontein Road under a blue sky, with the striped fascia, the fish logo and a Gatsby on the sign. Bring cash
Come hungry

63 Old Klipfontein Road, Athlone.

Opening hours

Trading hours
Monday08h30 – 18h00
Tuesday08h30 – 18h00
Wednesday08h30 – 18h00
Thursday08h30 – 18h00
Friday08h30 – 12h30 · 14h00 – 18h30
Saturday08h00 – 15h00
SundayClosed
  • Cash only
  • Parking bays out front
  • A short walk west of Wembley Roadhouse

Website preview by Atlantic Motion Studio · Live until 30 October

Book a call →